臨時オフィスに戻ったロッシ達は、エミリーから情報を受け取った。1980年の殺人事件以前にこのコミュニティで起きた事件のリスト。DUI(Driving Under the Influence: 飲酒運転)、窃盗、レイプ、暴行。さらにガルシアから連絡。全国の事件について今回の手口を調べてみたが関連性のあるものはゼロ。そこでこの場所に近い地域を調べてみると、隣の区域にカレン・フォリー(Karen Foley)という女性が起こした訴状が見つかった。事件全体は口にするにも恐ろしいが、簡単に言えば(原語: PG version, Penelope Garciaの頭文字)、彼女は1979年に誘拐された後に逃げ出した、というものだ。
Karen: The wife? He tortured me every single night. Could you hear my screams?! Did you kiss him when he was finished with me?! Emily: Please, please, don't do this to yourself. Karen: What did she think he was doing in that barn every night?! Did you ask? Did you ask why he wanted to be away from you? Why?! Why didn't you stop him?! Why didn't you help?! Mary: I killed him!
--- Director: John Gallagher Writer: Debra J. Fisher, Erica Messer
Star: Shemar Moore as Derek Morgan Joe Mantegna as David Rossi Thomas Gibson as Aaron Hotchner Matthew Gray Gubler as Dr. Spencer Reid Paget Brewster as Emily Prentiss A.J. Cook as Jennifer 'JJ' Jareau Kirsten Vangsness as Penelope Garcia
Guest Star: Nathan Sutton as Justin Lacey Beeman as Molly McCarthy Jesse Bernstein as Danny Curt Bonnem as Charlie Wilkinson Kandis Erickson as Julie Jeffrey Corbett as Michael Ballantyne W. Morgan Sheppard as John Caulfield Jennifer Hetrick as Mary Wilkinson Rodney Eastman as Stephen Foley Rebekah Brandes as Young Karen Foley Matt Hoffman (I) as Robert Wilkinson Sally Pressman as Chrissy Wilkinson Erika Whalen as Girl Houston Rhines as Guy J. Claude Deering as Man Royce Thomas Johnson as Boy Elizabeth Ann Roberts as Tara
Music: "Honky Tonk Women" by The Rolling Stones "Skin and Bones" by JET "Decoration Day" by Drive-By Truckers "Where the Devil Don't Stay" by Drive-By Truckers